Songs
- Loser, BabyAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Keith David, & Blake RomanE
- Stayed GoneAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Christian Borle, Amir Talai, & Joel PerezE
- Hell Is ForeverAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Alex Brightman, & Erika HenningsenE
- More Than AnythingAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Jeremy Jordan, & Erika Henningsen
- Hell’s Greatest DadAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Jeremy Jordan, Amir Talai, Erika Henningsen, & Kimiko Glenn
- RespectlessAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Lilly Cooper, & James Monroe IglehartE
- Out For LoveAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, & Daphne Rubin-Vega
- You Didn’t KnowAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Shoba Narayan, Patina Miller, Jessica Vosk, & Stephanie BeatrizE
- FinaleAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Jeremy Jordan, Amir Talai, Stephanie Beatriz, Blake Roman, Keith David, Christian Borle, Joel Perez, Kimiko Glenn, & Krystina AlabadoE
- Whatever It TakesAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Stephanie Beatriz, & James Monroe Iglehart
- Ready For ThisAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, Leslie Kritzer, Amir Talai, Kimiko Glenn, Alex Brightman, & Blake Roman
- It Starts With SorryAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Alex Brightman, Erika Henningsen, Stephanie Beatriz, & Blake Roman
- Welcome To HeavenAndrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Darren Criss, Shoba Narayan, & Patina Miller
- More Than Anything [Reprise]Andrew Underberg, Sam Haft, Erika Henningsen, & Stephanie Beatriz