Songs
- When He Sees MeKimiko Glenn, Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle & Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble
- Fit Right InKimiko Glenn, Vanessa Hudgens, James Marsden, & My Little Pony
- Who Is She?Kimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong and Megan Hilty
- Rider's Lullaby (Reprise)Kimiko Glenn
- What If I Forget Your FaceKimiko Glenn
- TaurnadoKimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong and The Centaurworld Cast
- The Next ThingKimiko Glenn, Jessie Mueller, Megan Hilty, Renée Elise Goldsberry and The Centaurworld Cast
- Battle RoundKimiko Glenn, Megan Hilty, Megan Nicole Dong, Josh Radnor, Parvesh Cheena and Chris Diamantopoulos
- Who Was SheKimiko Glenn
- Frustration TearsKimiko Glenn
- All Night LongKimiko Glenn
- Done with cryin'Kimiko Glenn
- King of BanditsKimiko Glenn
- Who Is She? (Reprise)Kimiko Glenn